ELA Post #4; Graphic Novels
I don’t have much experience with Graphic Novels in a Secondary Education setting, I think the closest I got was analyzing a political cartoon in middle school and that was it. In college though, I’ve experienced a few graphic novels and I, as a student, find them confusing. It’s one thing to be able to make up your own mind about characters and how they look and act, but it’s another to read one thing and get a completely different idea of how the character responds visually in the text. But, despite my inability to understand graphic novels, I can see how graphic novels can help students process and understand a text better. I could also see graphic novels being introduced to middle schoolers to help develop their understanding of symbolism and connecting the text to real world concepts and ideas with the help of identifying these with pictures provided by the author and illustrator. Graphic novels can also introduce a complicated topic, like in “American Born Chinese” by Gene Luen Yang, where Yang introduces a complicated topic of racism and stereotypes that is instilled in second generation immigrant going through middle and high school. With a funny, stereotypical character, a magical Monkey King, and an epiphany at the end, it’s a great read to introduce to a Secondary Education classroom and start a real discussion about a huge problem that students will have to face at some point. And a discussion Not based solely on the storyline, but how the characters are showed as well- from Chinkee’s luggage being Chinese takeout boxes, to the “transformation” of Jin. Not only will students have to dissect the text, but the images as well carry a whole other meaning behind the words on the page.
Comments
Post a Comment